Compare and Contrast Two Views of Gay Marriage Essay
815 Words4 Pages
William Bennett, editor of The Book of Virtues and co-director of Empower America, responded to an article that Andrew Sullivan had written supporting gay marriage in America. Bennett started out by first issuing two key points as to what divides the proponents and opponents of same-sex marriages. The two articles are derived from Sibylle Gruber’s Constructing Others: Constructing Ourselves edition. Bennett notions that legalizing same-sex marriage would weaken the meaning of it and outlines what the basic concept of marriage is. Throughout the article Bennett argues why same-sex marriage should not be legalized by moving from religion to the traditional concept of marriage between men and women, which he claims has a…show more content…
Responding to Sullivan’s article, William Bennett argues, “Marriage is based on natural teleology, on the different, complementary nature of men and women and how they refine, support, encourage and complete one another” (27).
The battle of marriage between gay couples is one of the most intense and relentless arguments in today’s society. Sullivan tries to express his ideas on how same-sex marriage is only the righteous thing to do for all gay men and women in America by establishing a sense of equality among U.S. citizens. Bennett responds by arguing that if same-sex marriage is allowed throughout the U.S., it would deter the meaning of marriage and the youth of our nation. Throughout the debate between the two individuals, Bennett painstakingly implies that Sullivan has a loose argument that is full of holes. Sullivan’s article is full of sexual biases, which defends his own purpose for writing the article (27-29).
As Bennett established his reason for opposing gay marriage, President Bush also seems to believe the same reasons. Bush’s support for an amendment proposed to banning gay marriage is not taken lightly to individuals, such as when Dean E. Murphy writes that Mayor Gavin Newsom recalled Mr. Bush’s remarks against
Same-sex Marriage People’s Rights
When asked if gay couple should have equal rights our soon to be president of the United States said, “No, no!” and that he doesn’t support gay marriage at all. If the soon to be president of the United States doesn’t accept gay people, why should the rest of us agree with it? Tulane.edu says, “Regardless of race, ethnicity, or religion, men and women across the world are guaranteed under international law the opportunity to enter into marriage with one another.” We the people of the United States said that all people are created equal. So why are gay people's rights being challenged? Why are they being treated as if they are different from us?
The NAACP said, “One of the key civil rights struggles of our time.” They say same-sex marriage is a civil right, and taking that away and challenging it would be a crime. On the other hand J. Matt Barber, Associate Dean for online programs at Liberty University School of law states, “Every individual engaged in the homosexual lifestyle, who has adopted a homosexual identity, they know, intuitively, that what they’re doing is immoral, unnatural, and self-destructive, yet they thirst for that affirmation.” J. Matt Barber feels that being gay is unnatural and shouldn’t be accepted by the American people. Many celebrities such as Anne Hathaway stated, “I’m not being brave; I’m being a decent human being. And I don’t think I should receive an award for that or for merely stating what I believe to be true: that love is a human experience, not a political statement.” Anne feels that the brave people are the gay people not the people who openly say they support it. People that come out and say they support gay marriages and couples are admired, but people that are actually gay are frowned upon. Our first amendment states that we have the freedom of speech, and that we are entitled to our own opinions. Although discriminating and beating down someone for their lifestyle and who they love is completely and utterly wrong.
According to Miami-Dade county circuit court Judge Sarah Zabel said, “Serves only to hurt, to discriminate, to deprive same-sex couples and their families of equal dignity, to label and treat them as second-class citizens, and to deem them unworthy of participation in one of the fundamental institutions of our society.” Judge Sarah feels that people not accepting gays are making them feel as they are a second-class. That they’re somehow below the rest of us, because of who they love. Conversely 6th US district court appeals judge Jeffrey S. Sutton wrote, “Marriage has long been a social institution defined by relationships between men and women. So long defined, the tradition is measured in millennia, not centuries or decades. So widely shared, the tradition until recently had been adopted by all governments and the major religions of the world.” Judge Jeffrey S. Sutton feels that marriage is becoming less and less important and sentimental because we have made gay marriage a right to the people. Matthew Morrison says, “I love gay people, so I’m not going to be insulted or angry by being called gay. As a straight man standing up for the LGBT community, I feel a sense of responsibility to make sure that people know that being gay is not a negative.” Many male actors are considered gay, Morrison who is straight doesn’t feel offended when people say he is gay. He feels he needs to stand up for the gay people considering people so often call him gay even though he is straight. So often many people think that being gay is a negative thing, I find that as a positive thing. Being able to express your love is a beautiful thing that should not be beaten down by others. Expressing your love should be praised not degraded.
A study by Social Science Quarterly found that, “Laws permitting same-sex marriage or civil unions have no adverse effect on marriage, divorce, and abortion rates, or the percent of children born out of wedlock.” This helps prove that gay marriage doesn’t affect other people, or other things that happen in the world. Other people are saying the US constitution contains no explicit right to marry. Saying marriage is a privilege, not a right. This statement states marriage isn't a law and that it is not guaranteed as a right to the people of the United States. Lena Dunham feels, “The idea of having a celebration that can’t be fully shared among all the people in my life and all the people that we love just doesn’t really feel like a celebration at all.” Lena feels that celebrating the love and marriage of gay people isn’t really a celebration.” That it’s really hard to celebrate these things because of their rights being denied and that they could only get married in certain states during that time. Gay marriage or any marriage should be a celebration. Not a thing that should be disowned and beaten down because it’s different from yours or any other person’s marriage.
Everyone should accept gay people, gay couples, and gay marriage. They should be accepted and have the same amount of respect as any other person in these here United States of America. Just because they love someone of the same-sex doesn’t mean they should be beaten down for it, they deserve the same amount of rights and respect as anybody else. This goes for everyone we need to stop discriminating, and stop making the gays feel that they are a second-class because of the people they love.
Gay Marriage Research Paper Example:
The issue focused on in traditional marriage is that it’s viewed for procreation between a male and female. Since it’s considered “normal” people view homosexuals as unordinary and decide not to accept them. Everyone should be for gay marriage because we need to respect others decisions, marriage is a choice, and it isn’t just for procreation. Gay rights movement have been happening since the 1960’s which demonstrates that this dispute for equality is still going on(Bush). Gay right activism in the 1970’s focused on liberation rather than getting married. Not only was gay marriage something people had to protest about but to have equality in society.
People get married to procreate which is why gay marriage is unacceptable. Everyone’s taught that marriage is between a male and female because they can reproduce. Although they can create children starting a family is their choice. According to “Lifelong Adoptions” homosexual parents raised four percent of adopted children in the United States. This implies how there are other ways to start a family, but also not every gay couple wants to start one. Marriage is tying the knot with the person that you love, but starting a family is a tradition which is why many people don’t agree with gay marriage since they can’t produce with each other. In 2014, 47.6 percent of women between age 15 and 44 had never had children. Therefore not every woman who is married wants to have children. It is believed that every married woman wants to have children but it’s not true, so it shows that procreation is a choice.
Gays aren't treated equally because they’re “sinning” with their choice. No matter what sex orientation you are in the end we are all human and deserve to be treated equally. Statistics show that about 20 percent of students are physically assaulted because of their sexual orientation(Gates). Many students and adults who have a different sexual orientation are at risk of being abused, bullied, and even killed by other people(Gates). People shouldn’t be abused for choosing their identity, or for being different. This has been an ongoing problem that shouldn’t even be happening. According to “PFLAG New York City” gay teens are 8 times more likely to commit suicide or have high levels of depressions. In our teen age we tend to try to fit in with trends while others who are looking for their own identity get bullied. Therefore not only is it hard for teens to find their identity, but it is also hard to understand that there will always be people who won’t agree with what you do or who you are.
Marriage is only for a man and a woman. Due to religion, people would punish homosexuals for having a different sexual orientation. Facts such as this show that gays and lesbians were punished by getting whipped and thrown in jail for “committing a crime”(Bearak, Cameron). In countries such as Afghanistan, Iran, Nigeria, and Saudi Arabia homosexuals are flogged or killed. This conveys how people have no respect and are selfish into thinking that they’re doing the right thing. Back then having a different sexual orientation was seen as an act of sin since it was an uncommon thing to do. In every century things change, people change so it’s time for us to accept others to love whoever they want as long as they’re not harming others or themselves. Research shows that 60% of attacks in 2013 were against homosexuals(Latest Hate Crime Statistic Report Released.) They’ve been targeted because of their choice and people believe that killing them is going to help others. Killing people for their love choice has become common and people still don’t teach their children or family that we should all respect our peers.
To sum it up, the world is accustomed t the tradition which is why it’s so difficult for people to accept homosexuals. Marriage is a sign of commitment, but starting a family is an extra part to life. This has always been an irregular argument, so now it’s time to break the barrier and let everyone have equality. A married couple doesn’t have to start a family or procreate because there are other ways, and some couples just don’t want children. So, if people are able to marry a person with a different religion or race then why can’t someone marry another person with the same gender?